If ever there was someone who could be described as an enigma then Thelma Gutsche must certainly fit the description, for she seems to be a largely unexplored treasure of South African history. Her seminal work on South African cinema, The History and Social Significance of Motion Pictures in South Africa 1895 – 1940, as well as her many other major biographical works , essays and contributions to encyclopedias, newspapers and magazines, attest to the prodigious output of this South African historian, author and social commentator. Apart from the thorough and lengthy academic paper on Thelma Gutsche prepared by Ntongela Masilela “Thelma Gutsche: A Great South African Film Scholar”, there is very little other information published about the academic who was such an important social and historical commentator of South African life of the late 19 th and early 20 th century.
Thelma Gutsche is acknowledged as a South African film scholar, which might at first create confusion, given that her major work on the social and historical significance of film in South Africa is based on European and American film and not South African made film. Her work should rather be understood as an analysis of the social and cultural effects that European and American film had on South African audiences. Given an understanding of how Thelma Gutsche fits the description of a South African film scholar, one is bound to ask why she is included in a collection of work dedicated to the New African Movement.
As a white South African writing about European and American film in a South African context, one might not immediately make the connection between Thelma Gutsche and her inclusion in a body of work on the New African Movement. This intellectual movement was primarily concerned with the introduction of the concepts of modernity into South Africa and their propagation through the literature and politics of mainly Black South Africans, a New African modernity as opposed to a South African modernity. However, Thelma Gutsche is recognized as having made a contribution to South African modernity in that the content of both her major work on South African film and her biographical works deal with concepts such as “the importance of cities as cultural and social spaces for the realization of certain happenings of modernity” (Masilela 4), “delineating sports as the necessity of modernity” (Masilela 4), and how “the mining revolution unleashed modernity” (Masilela 5).
Examining the life of Thelma Gutsche, it becomes apparent that her sensibilities and manners were patently of a European and British nature, which undoubtedly accounted for her bias toward European film as opposed to the sensationalism of American film. Given that the concept of modernity in South Africa was ultimately based on the precepts of the European Renaissance, a period of revival throughout Europe marking the transition into modern times, one is tempted to draw connections between Thelma Gutsche's penchant for European film and the fact that the concept of modernity was ushered into the world via Europe . Ntongela Masilela has already dealt with the academic examination of Thelma Gutsche's work in ”Thelma Gutsche: A Great South African Film Scholar”. Of interest here, in order to gather a more comprehensive picture of this larger than life individual who had such a great part to play on the examination of the social and historical relevance of early South African cinema, is to investigate beyond the persona of the academic and to read into the ‘text' of Thelma Gutsche's personal life.
Thelma Gutsche was born in Somerset West in the Cape Province , in the then ‘Union of South Africa' in 1915, the younger daughter of Dr and Mrs J Gutsche (Becker 2). She never attended a school but was privately tutored at home, the individual attention and her intellect no doubting contributing to the fact that she matriculated at the tender age of 14. Two years later, she entered the University of Cape Town , aged 16, to begin her B.A. studies in Ethics, Logic, Philosophy and Psychology (Viljoen 2). She went on to complete her M.A. in Ethics, Logic and Metaphysics. After graduating, she moved to Johannesburg to take up a position with the weekly newspaper “The Forum”, writing reviews for films from 1938 until 1939. Thelma Gutsche apparently loved the “south of Africa” with “an abiding passion (…) especially the Cape Province , but did not like Johannesburg , although she knew it well, (Becker 43) and would go on to publish books on the city .
Gutsche went on to write a series of articles on the South African film industry for the Cape Times between 1937 and1950. During World War II, she became a film adviser to the South African government as well as writing scripts for documentaries and directing films. Following the war she went on to make a number of educational films (Viljoen 2).
Thelma Gutsche was undoubtedly a young woman of privilege, her father being the former Manager of De Beers Dynamite Factory and later the director of the South African Paper and Pulp Industries, Ltd. Johannesburg (Untitled). Thelma Gutsche mixed with extremely well connected and influential individuals, becoming very close to the likes of Parliamentarian Barn Friedman and his wife Lulu, with whom she had lifelong friendships (Becker 35–50). Gutsche went into the publishing business with Lulu Friedman and two other male acquaintances, but ‘Silver Leaf Books', their publishing venture, proved to be unsuccessful, publishing only two titles: Zulu Paradox , by Hugh Tracey, and Face to Face , the first published book of Nadine Gordimer (Becker 40). Thelma Gutsche was also befriended by Princess Alice, Countess of Athlone, when the Earl was Governor-General of South Africa (Becker 43). Years later (circa 1979/1980), on the occasion of the Princess's 95 th birthday, Dr Gutsche sent the Princess a copy of her book There was a Man – The Life and Times of Sir Arnold Theiler , via her friend Barn Friedmann, the Princess having expressed great interest in Dr Gutsche's long and intense research into the life of Theiler (Goosen 8).
In 1946, eleven years after leaving the Cape, Thelma Gutsche was awarded her Doctorate in Social History from the University of Cape Town under the guidance of Prof. F C L Bosman. Her thesis topic was: The History and Social Significance of Motion Pictures in South Africa 1895 – 1940. This would only come to be published in book form by the Human Sciences Research Council in South Africa , more than thirty years later, due to scholarly demand from students (The Argus 4). During this time, Gutsche was working for African Consolidated Theatres, as head of their Documentary Film section, (Becker 40) a period which no doubt had some measure of influence on chapter X (‘Kinemas break the “monopoly” and introduce “talkies” – formation of African Consolidated Theatres and Films Ltd 1927 – 1931') of the published book version of her thesis.
In a speech to the Council for Women (Gutsche 1-7) Thelma Gutsche's words displayed her fiercely independent streak and favoring of women's rights, stating that “[w]hile [she was] in full sympathy with the aim of the new ‘Women for Peace' (to which [she did] not belong), [she] would give [her] full support to ‘Women for Strife' – strife against discrimination in all its forms: sex, color, race, culture, education, religion – all the causes of war” (Gutsche 2-3). She talked about it being a time for forceful attack on the evils of our society. “From the dawn of time, women have always been regarded as the custodians of decency and refinement, even in the most repressive communities”.
It appears as if Thelma Gutsche was a bit of a paradox; she was a most independent woman, ahead of her times, but could also be severely conservative in her outlook: cosmopolitan but neurotic; tweeds versus her signature cigarette-holders. She was a woman who drove her open sports car with the hood down but was also conservative and upright. She was practical, industrious, a workaholic and staunchly loyal (Becker 37). She was a woman who displayed a wide variety of interests and possessed an investigative spirit. Even in her late 60s, when she was retired in Montagu, her industriousness caused her to continue to work late into the night on her research.
She is described by a friend as “generous-hearted, (…) never willingly wound[ing] (…) anybody's amour propre ” (Becker 37). She was a loyal friend who, at the age of 67, in December 1982, already rather frail, drove the long road to Johannesburg all alone in her old car to see her ailing, long-time friend, Barn Friedman.
Thelma had elaborate manners and was very fastidious, an eccentric, elegant, and dramatic woman (Becker 36) with a “small, high-pitched voice” and “ a slight lisp” (Becker 35). “[S]he was tall, thin, very elegant. In dress, gesture, manner, atmosphere, she was like nobody else” and “[s]tyle was of great importance to Thelma” (Becker 35).
Although she is reported to have enjoyed the company of men “[a]ll Thelma's closest and most intimate relationships were with women” (Becker 37). For all her busy life though, she expressed a horror of aloneness when one had longed for and stood supported by a companionship suddenly withdrawn” on the demise of her friendship with Lulu Friedman (Becker 42). She was said to be a cantankerous and truculent woman in the latter part of her life, ill-tempered, quarrelsome, and fierce (Becker 47). She developed emphysema as a result of her lifelong habit of smoking but stubbornly refused to give it up.
Dr Gutsche was always involved in the community around her, giving of her time and expertise, and was responsible for either founding or becoming deeply involved in many worthy causes: she was a member of the Africana Museum Advisory Committee from March, 1956; she served as a Founding member and Trustee of the Association of Friends of the Johannesburg Art Gallery, and eventually became their Honorary Life President; she served on the Consultative Committee of the Bensusan Museum of Photography from 1968, until August 1981, when she resigned because of her retirement to Montagu (Africana Notes and News 186); and was a founding member of the Simon van der Stel Foundation, a non-profit, private organization that conserves and restores buildings of historical and architectural importance, reflecting her belief in the importance of historical detail. She was also an active member of the National Council of Women in South Africa , becoming President of the Council at one stage, and traveled to Athens to address the International Council of Women (Becker 41). Thelma Gutsche continued to support and work for the causes she believed in after her retirement.
Thelma Gutsche was an “indefatigable researcher and author of works of biographical and social interest” (Becker 35). She criss-crossed the Karoo on her own in her search for places, relics and reminiscences of her biographees (Becker 48). Thelma Gutsche was renowned for being painstakingly meticulous in her work. She approached her research on Arnold Theiler, the book of which took ten years to write, with a scientific thoroughness, interviewing Theiler's family, friends and work colleagues, even traveling to Switzerland to track down relatives and papers connected to Theiler. In her work there was an emphasis on facts, and she exhibited a balanced, sober judgment, shying away from any emotional involvement. The nature of her research methods were arguably allied with the rationalism of the European Enlightenment, scientific and factual (Suid-Afrikaanse Oorsig).
Gutsche, in her dissertation, created a structural mapping of her thesis that was to influence all of her later work. Masilela communicates this notion as being a theme that tames, controls and orders chaos, for example “motion pictures” ordering the “cultural space” of the cinema, bringing European civilization into Africa (Masilela 3). Her later works follow a similar theme, for example, her work on Arnold Theiler , according to Masilela, “is about classifying and ordering of Nature, the formation of medical institutions with the aim of making and creating space for European cultural forms in Africa: in other words, the bringing of European civilization into Africa (Masilela 3).
Thelma Gutsche regarded herself as “a biographer and public servant” (The Argus 4). She is reported to have stated in an interview that she was not interested in national heroes, statesmen and war veterans, and wanted to write about the men and women that did pioneering work in South Africa, in their historical perspective. She wanted to write about the unsung heroes (Suid-Afrikaanse Oorsig). Masilela reiterates this notion in his essay on Thelma Gutsche, commenting on her contempt for South African film and the way in which it foregrounded white, Afrikaner nationalism (Masilela 16). You will not find any writing by Thelma Gutsche on the generals, presidents and patriots of early South Africa. Unfortunately, there is no body of work by Gutsche on any of the foremost Black South African personalities that so largely contributed to the process of modernity in South Africa, but like most South Africans, until very recently, the work of these early pioneers was largely unknown outside of their own communities.
Gutsche was apparently an admirer of Vera Brittain, the British pacifist, feminist, poet, and novelist. Brittain's novels are largely autobiographical. Her best-known work is Testament of Youth (1933), a story of 'the lost generation' and the irrevocable changes in her life caused by World War I. There is a sense that Gutsche's admiration for Brittain is a reflection of the parallels between their works in as much as Gutsche analyzed the influence of film on South African audiences in a period of dramatic change, as well as the irrevocable changes brought about in South African modernity by a number of her biographeees.
A fighter and defender of the importance of historical detail to the end, when the historic houses of Long Street, where she lived in her last days, were being structurally threatened by heavy trucks, she had the following to say to a reporter from the Weekend Argus newspaper in Cape Town: “The street is being destroyed by a monster of modern society and positive action has to be taken to preserve this important sector of our heritage”. She is reported to have characteristically fought “tooth and nail” to have the heavy traffic re-routed (Brown 12).
Many years after leaving, Thelma Gutsche returned to her beloved Cape from the Transvaal to spend her last years in the Cape village of Montagu, making her home in a historical Victorian house that she had long set her heart on, number 47 Long Street (Becker 35). In what turned out to be her last year of life, Thelma Gutsche was invited to give the Theiler Memorial Lecture at Pretoria University in September, 1984. Having had a rather dramatic time trying to get there, (driving alone she had rolled her car, writing it off) she went on to receive the first ever standing ovation after the delivery of her lecture (Becker 46, 49). Her smoking induced emphysema worsened, and she died less than two months later on November 5, 1984, seated at her desk in her house in Montagu, aged 69 (Becker 35).
Becker, Jillian. “No ordinary woman – Dr Thelma Gutsche: a memoir.” Contrast 15.3(1985): 35-50.
Brown, Robin. “Mobile ‘monsters' threaten historic Montagu houses” The Weekend Argus 21 Jul. 1984:12.
“Death of Dr Thelma Gutsche” Africana Notes and News, 26 Mar. 1985:5, 186-188.
“Death of Dr Thelma Gutsche” The Argus 7 Nov. 1984:4.
Goosen, Helena. “ Helena Goosen ontmoet dr. Thelma Gutsche” Suid-Afrikaanse Oorsig 474a(1981):8.
Gutsche, Thelma. “Civilisation and the Interrupted Sex.” South Africa. “Natal Society Public Library.”
Masilela, Ntongela. “Thelma Gutsche: A Great South African Film Scholar.” 5 Nov. 2005, http://www.pitzer.edu/academics/faculty/masilela/nam/general/essays/gutsche.htm.
Untitled. South Africa 4 Sep. 1937: CXCV (1937) 25 39, 280.
Viljoen, Deon. “Thelma Gutsche Oorlede” Kalender Bylae tot Bee ld 10 Nov. 1984:2.
Works published, writing:
Michelle Christian is a third year undergraduate student at the University of KwaZulu Natal in Durban, South Africa. She is studying towards her Bachelor of Social Sciences degree and is enrolled in the Culture, Communication and Media Studies program. Michelle is currently an exchange student at Pitzer College in Claremont, California. At the end of her semester at Pitzer she will return to Durban to complete her honors year in 2006.