Organizational Studies 100: Organizational Theory
Fall Semester, 2016

 

Meeting Time: Mondays and Wednesdays, 11:00 – 12:15

Room: Fletcher Hall 112

 

Professor: Jeff Lewis

Office: Fletcher 214  Phone: 607-3069 

E-Mail: jeff_lewis@pitzer.edu

Web page: http://www.pitzer.edu/~jlewis

Office hours: Mondays at 2:30 pm, Wednesdays at 10 am, and by appointment

 

Texts:

1. Morgan, Gareth (2006). Images of Organizations (Revised Edition). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

2. Senge, Peter, , Smith Bryan, Kruschwitz, Nina, Laur, Joe, and Schley, Sara (2010). The Necessary Revolution: How Individuals and Organizations are Working Together to Create a Sustainable World. New York: Bantum Books

3. Assorted readings posted on Sakai. Note that additional readings will be posted throughout the semester, and these additions will be noted during class meetings.

 

Goals of the Course

 

This class examines the major ideas that shape the way we think about how people and institutions organize their groups and work settings. Organizational theorists include a long list from F. W. Taylor and Max Weber, to systems theorists, postmodern and more recent scholars. Using metaphors as our vantage point, we hope to obtain fuller understanding of each view as we contrast important perspectives and theoretical orientations.  After a thorough review, we will also examine key concepts and core issues from contemporary and classic views of organizational theory. Organizations and Sustainability emerges as the focus in the latter part of the class when we will shift to discussing how organizations can be designed to better address larger environmental pressures.

 

This course and the Organizational Studies major as a whole are also aligned with the college’s educational objectives. In this course it is hoped that students’ work will exemplify critical thinking, effective expression, interdisciplinary appreciation, intercultural understanding, and ethical evaluations.

 

In addition, this course is designed to help students achieve the following objectives:

 

 

Expectations

Your active participation in this course will enhance not only your learning but also the experience we co-create in this class. You are expected to prepare fully prior to the class, reading the assigned material before the class sessions and coming prepared with questions that you want answered. The major assignments in this course allow for extended preparation, and working with your fellow students as you absorb the material is encouraged. Good cooperation and conscientiousness when engaged in collaborative work is crucial and should be characteristic of all team projects in this course. Individual papers and assignments are exclusively your own product, however, and it is expected that works collected from you to meet these course requirements will be of your own creation. You are required to adhere to the College’s Code of Student Conduct, which upholds academic integrity and prohibits academic dishonesty, including those forms of academic dishonesty that are listed in the Pitzer College Student Handbook.

 

Course Requirements
     Take-Home Essay Exams (45%) class topics and edited discussion questions used in class will form the basis for the take-home exams. I hope this will help us focus our discussion and motivate the exploration of the topics each question raises.  There will be three take-home exams, each covering approximately one third of the course material.

 

     Metaphorical Case Analysis (35%): One of the main themes in this course will be the use of different models or metaphors for organizations, where the taking of new perspectives will help us understand important aspects of organizational life and function. For this assignment, you will be asked to prepare a short analysis of an organizational experience of your choice. You can select either an organization you worked in or one you can research, but your selection should allow for a vivid and thought-provoking extension of the class material. The paper should highlight a significant issue confronting the organization, apply two perspectives from Morgan’s work, evaluate potential directions and take into account the views of relevant stakeholders.

 

     Class participation (20%) – Each week you are expected to contribute your thoughts and analysis of the readings and to complete any weekly assignment. You will also be asked to contribute to the class activities related to group presentations and hand in any in-class work throughout the semester. While attendance is not required, frequent absences are likely to diminish your learning, and as, it is important to interact, connect to the material and support your fellow classmates as we construct our learning environment, your overall grade may also suffer.    

 

     Writing Center – Located in 131 Mead Hall, just across from the fountain, the Pitzer Writing Center offers students free one-on-one conferences with peer Fellows trained to consult on assignments in all disciplines at any stage of the writing process, from brainstorming ideas to polishing a final draft.  The Writing Center is one of Pitzer’s most popular academic resources, holding over 1,500 appointments each year.  I strongly urge you to make early and frequent use of this resource throughout the writing process.  Please visit the Writing Center’s website for more information:  http://pitweb.pitzer.edu/writing-center  

 

Students from other campuses are encouraged to visit their local Writing Centers:

 

                     Claremont McKenna Center for Writing and Public Discourse: http://www.claremontmckenna.edu/writing/  

                     Harvey Mudd College Writing Center: https://www.hmc.edu/learning-programs/writing-center/ 

                     Pomona Writing Center: http://www.pomona.edu/academics/resources/writing-center/center/  

                     Scripps Writing Center: http://www.scrippscollege.edu/departments/writing-program/writing-center  


                      

Schedule of Lectures and Readings

Week and Topical Focus

Readings and assignments

August 31st                      Organizing the class

---

 

 

September 5th & 7th         Theories and Organizations

Sakai Reading - Hatch Ch. 1 & Astley & Van de Ven (1983)

 

 

September 12th & 14th  

Metaphors and Concepts

Morgan Ch. 1; Sakai Readings  (S) - Hatch Ch. 2

 

 

September 19th & 21st

Organizations as Machines

Morgan Ch. 2; S – Taylor’s principles & Weber on Bureaucracy

 

September 26th & 28th  

 Organic model

Morgan Ch. 3; S – Luthans & Stewart (1977)

 

 

October 3rd & 5th

 Learning Organizations

Morgan Ch. 4; S – Fiol & Lyles (1985)

Take-Home Exam one due in dropbox on 10-5

October 10th & 12th          Cultural Perspective

Morgan Ch. 5

                               

Fall Break – October 15th through October 18th (no class on October 17th)

 

October 19th                       Politics and Power

      Morgan Ch. 6; S – Wiltermuth & Flynn (2013)

Paper Proposals due in dropbox by 10-19  

 

October 24th & 26th           Psychic Prisons 

      Morgan Ch. 7

 

Oct. 31st & Nov. 2nd          Chaos and Complexity

      Morgan Ch. 8; S- Brown & Eisenhardt (1999)

 

November 7th & 9th           Domination

  Morgan Ch. 9

                                Take-Home Exam two due in dropbox on 11-9

November 14th & 16th     

 Call for Sustainability

 

Senge et al. Chs. 1-4; S – Bansal & Roth (2000)

 

 

November 21st                  Strategies and Relationships

    Senge et al. Chs. 5-9

                              

Thanksgiving Break November 24th – 27th (no class November 23rd)

 

November 28th & 30th        Systems and Collaboration      

   Senge et al. Chs. 12-17

 

December 5th & 7th           Future paths                                Senge et al. Chs. 19-26

 

                        Final: Third Take-Home exam and Case Papers due during finals week

 

ORST100: Organizational Theory

Case Analysis Paper: Applying Morgan’s metaphors

 

Prepare and submit a case study that analyzes an organization’s experience using some of the lenses provided by Morgan. The case situation could be one where you were either a participant, close observer or otherwise can obtained detailed knowledge through published sources.  Your paper should loosely follow the method outlined in Chapter 11 of Images, and your analysis should be centered on a practice, events, or an outcome that you believe would be illustrative of important points of contrast.  In general, your analysis should show how the metaphorical lenses allow us to see different things from the evidence you describe, and your comparison and contrast should be based on the concepts introduced in Morgan with help from other class material. Your paper should:

 

·         Describe the case, providing adequate detail for the reader to gain a sense of the context, important stakeholders as well as the events and issues at hand.

·         Following from the example case described in Chapter 11, apply Morgan’s method and examine the experience from two contending metaphorical perspectives in a way that demonstrates an understanding of the key elements of each perspective as discussed in the relevant chapters.

·         Critically evaluate the assertions based on the available data and conclude with an evaluation of the worth of what was gleaned from each perspective.

 

The paper should not exceed 12 pages in length (not including your reference section) and use the APA formatting and documentation style or its equivalent. A proposal that introduces your selected case, the chosen metaphorical perspectives you plan to apply, and listing of key sources for background material and support is due after fall break.

 

The structure of your paper will vary depending upon the problem you are addressing, but one might tackle an issue by dealing with some of the following points:

 

·         A historical overview that situates the organization into their present state.

·         What changes have occurred and what challenges do they face?

·         Listing of operations or programs already attempted or underway, and proposed possibilities for the future.

·         Key decisions made and an evaluation of their outcomes.

 

This introduction should provide enough detail to enable you to illustrate key aspects of your chosen metaphorical perspectives. After the descriptive summary that brings us to the present state, apply two of Morgan’s metaphors to help interpret events, operations and/or practices. Sometimes the issues you address may be due to competing worldviews or holding on to a belief system that worked in the past but now is beyond its usefulness. But in many cases, two or more possible perspectives may be operating and neither is correct in any objective sense. They simply lead to different conclusions.

 

When applying the metaphors, you should be able to explain the situation from each point of view, state a determination of the problem and then offer viable solutions for the challenges faced. Once these are stated, use research findings cited in Morgan and elsewhere to help you assess the viability of solutions that would follow from each view.